Skip to content

Click here to view our Upcoming Signings schedule!

Click here to view our Upcoming Signings schedule!

All categories

Your #1 Source for 100% Authentic Sports Memorabilia!

Your #1 Source for 100% Authentic Sports Memorabilia!

Home
About Us
Charity Auctions
MLB
NBA
NFL
NHL
TTM Athletes
Upcoming Signings
Past Signings
Contact Us

Login

Login

Home
About Us
Charity Auctions
MLB
NBA
NFL
NHL
TTM Athletes
Upcoming Signings
Past Signings
Contact Us

Home New York Islanders Matthew Schaefer

New York Islanders

Filters

Player - Matthew Schaefer Remove filter

Interest

Team

1986 Mets
New York Islanders
New York Mets
New York Rangers
Notre Dame
USA Hockey

Player

Alexander Romanov
Anders Lee
Bo Horvat
Bobby Nystrom
Brock Nelson
Bryan Trottier
Butch Goring
Cal Clutterbuck
Casey Cizikas
Dennis Potvin
Eli Manning
Emil Heineman
Gary Cohen
Howie Rose
Ilya Sorokin
Ken Morrow
Kieffer Bellows
Lawrence Taylor
Mathew Barzal
Matt Martin
Matthew Schaefer
Noah Dobson
Phil Simms

Sort by

Show
24
36
48

View as

Player - Matthew Schaefer Remove filter

Sale

$129.00

| /

MYSTERY MATTHEW SCHAEFER HEADLINER NY Islanders 16x20 Photo MYSTERY Box Series #1 (10 Boxes)
Coach's Collectibles

MATTHEW SCHAEFER IS THE MEGA HEADLINER OF THIS SERIES!!!!!! You are purchasing a MYSTERY BOX with an autographed NY Islanders 16x20 Photo Inside! T...
View full details

$129.00

| /

Sale
Sale

$179.00

| /

MYSTERY MATTHEW SCHAEFER HEADLINER NY Islanders Framed 16x20 Photo MYSTERY Box Series #1 (10 Boxes)
Coach's Collectibles

MATTHEW SCHAEFER IS THE MEGA HEADLINER OF THIS SERIES!!!!!! You are purchasing a MYSTERY BOX with an autographed NY Islanders Framed 16x20 Photo In...
View full details

$179.00

| /

Sale

Sort by

You recently viewed

Follow us

Find us on Facebook Find us on Instagram

Main menu

Home
About Us
Charity Auctions
MLB
NBA
NFL
NHL
TTM Athletes
Upcoming Signings
Past Signings
Contact Us

Autographed Sports Memorabilia & Authentic Game Used Items

Whether searching for a baseball autographed by your favorite World Series slugger, a signed football by an iconic Hall of Famer, or the jersey of world famous soccer star, you've come to the right place!

Here at CoachsCollectiblesNY.com, you'll find authentic products from many professional sports leagues, teams, and players! Not only will you find your next prized sports possession with ease thanks to superb customer service, and tremendous site experience, you'll have the satisfaction and peace of mind that every product listed comes complete with a certificate of authenticity and is fully backed by the CoachsCollectiblesNY.com lifetime authenticity guarantee.

Search
Privacy Policy
Refund Policy
Shipping Policy
Terms of Service

Copyright © 2026 Coach's Collectibles.

Powered by Shopify

Added to your cart:

** total_quantity ** | ** unit_price ** / ** unit_measure **

(-)

Cart subtotal